Skip to main content

Preservation and Its Discontents: The Word According to Rem Koolhaas

The celebrated architect, architectural theorist, and Harvard University professor Rem Koolhaas gave the keynote speech for the Festival of Ideas for the New City on Wednesday night, and on Thursday morning, he introduced the exhibit "Cronocaos" in a preview at the New Museum. The exhibit, by his architectural partnership OMA (Office for Metropolitan Architecture) and his Rotterdam design studio AMO and first presented at the 2010 Venice Biennale, offers visual arguments, mostly ones of paradox and ambiguity, about the new regime of preservation. Building restrictions and regulations designed to preserve buildings or whole neighborhoods, a phenomenon that is worldwide, not only pose difficult choices for innovative designers but also may serve to corrupt memory itself by creating artificial historical environments. "If you preserve something," Koolhaas explained, "it becomes conserved and then something artificial."

"Cronocaos" at the New Museum
"Cronocaos," an exhibit at 231 Bowery, the New Museum's new ground-floor space.


Presented in the New Museum's ground floor space at 231 Bowery, Cronocaos examines the growing trend that seeks to conserve the past but frequently ends up limiting choices for innovative design and creativity. The exhibit space is intentionally bifurcated, with the right side "preserved," with remnants of the old restaurant supply store it occupies, and the left side partially renovated. Such is the chaos that preservation places on the soul of a modernist. The documents and arguments on display, guided in order by directional arrows marked on the floor, take in a variety of concerns. The sheer fact of the growing worldwide preservationist impulse has diminished the role of the architect, illustrated here with one panel showing TIME magazines with pictures of architects on the cover. The last one was Philip Johnson in 1979. As Koolhaas discussed at the preview, this diminished public role of the architect in the age of preservation may help counteract those who often frequently call him and others of his stature a "starchitect."

Rem Koolhaas speaking at preview for "Cronocaos" at New Museum
architect and theorist Rem Koolhaas speaking at a preview of "Cronocaos," May 5, 2011

A long wall of documents illustrates many projects of Koolhaas's firm, ones that forced the designers to confront the often aggravating, and mostly limiting, restrictions dictated by preservation. Some problems they resolved successfully. Their design for ITT's McCormick Tribune Campus Center on Chicago's South Side invigorated Mies van der Rohe's original campus from 1953, but they refused to leave the building untouched, as the preservationist demanded it. Other projects had to be abandoned, like their ideas for an irregular and looming extension for the Whitney Museum in 2001. The Landmark Preservation Commission wouldn't go for that sort of thing in old brownstone New York. Many projects are illustrated and cleverly described along this wall in the exhibit. Visitors are welcome to tear off and take home these illustrations and texts, affixed to the wall in multiples like a desktop calendar.

"Cronocaos" at the New Museum
OMA history, with illustrations of the firm's history with preservation.


Along the back wall, a rather humorous and pointed set of images argues that the repurposing of older industrial spaces, often gigantic, tends to breed equally gigantic art installations that often take as their themes various riffs on the "apocalyptic sublime." The designers compare the artwork to the set designs of B-movies of the horror genre, finding their aesthetics uncannily similar. It’s a fairly hilarious highlight of the exhibit although not easily understood as thematically consistent with the rest of Cronocaos.

Speaking of preservation, Koolhaas explained he "never pronounced the word until eight years ago," thinking the word symbolized "reactionary people who resist." Now he must come to terms with it, because it's so prevalent, but we don't argue enough about what it means. "Preservation has become a kind of default position," he said. "It's part of the repertoire of modernity."

"Cronocaos" at the New Museum
a panel illustrating four iterations of Berlin's Reichstag, leaving no mark of earlier history


As buildings and neighborhoods of New York increasingly fall under preservationist and landmark protections, it’s worth addressing how much we’re condemning parts of the city to an artificial past and whether or not we’ve made enough room for constructing new urban centers that could better serve the city’s social needs. What room is left for the new New York?

"Cronocaos" opens to the public today, May 7, and remains on view through June 5 at the New Museum's space at 231 Bowery.

Images by Walking Off the Big Apple from May 5, 2011.

Comments

RLewis said…
This man is just plain wrong. Wait until they want to tear down one of his buildings, and then see how quickly he screams for preservation.
Teri Tynes said…
Thank you for your comment. I expect many people will resist his ideas about preservation and memory, although I think he is challenging us to think about what we choose to preserve and why we enact preservationist regulations. Some things get saved; others do not. Actually, at the preview, he remarked that one of his own buildings had already been preserved, a fact that he found absurd, given how new it is.
Anonymous said…
What horses--t. NYC isn't turning into an "conserved" "artificial" environment because of what is preserved. It's becoming as dull as dust because all that's going up are highrise luxury condos; and anything, any business, any building, any community, that has a hint of a link to the past is erased.

You name it -- from the wreck of Coney Island to the rape of Prospect Heights (AKA Atlantic Yards) to the destruction of the Bowery, you can't say that preservation is even a little bit of the problem.
Blayze said…
Rem Koolhouse is the problem. Revoke his license, send him back to Berlin where his eyesores are appreciated.
Blayze said…
Rem doesn't care for cities, he cares for his shiny and often bland towers that make him lots of money. Walk through or around a block of his condos, or whatever eyesore he's left on New York, and then walk down any landmarked block in Brooklyn, or just any block in the city that hasn't seen the scar of modernist architecture.

You tell me which one is more appealing. Preservation needs to be expanded, lest we lose more of our history to what? More generic condos and overpriced housing.
onegun said…
Thank You Blayze,
You couldn't have said it better. I cringe when I walk down a once totally intact block in NYC, and something looming is in the center-making it look like the block could sink. What I first loved about NYC was its old and intact neighborhoods. They were my link to the past and the FUTURE. I used to walk blocks even out-of-my-way, because I just loved to walk that way because of the old and wonderful block I would take. Our old historic neighborhoods need to be preserved. Where there may be a place for new architecture, it should not mar the presence of very old and historic neighborhoods. It's time to preserve our history. The only reasons developing our old neighborhoods is because they are popular, but once you destroy them, they will not be popular, just boring.
Anton Deque said…
I was surprised to find there were even measures to protect New York's architectural heritage; I rather thought that was against the grain in America, a country keen on everyone else's history but not it's own. Attacks on M. Koolhaas may be entertaining (I am afraid I find these not much so) but they are besides the point. Tynes' has herself pointed out in her piece on the new Cooper Union Art School building how a radical building can articulate (make one see better?) the buildings around it. This thought came to me looking at the Daniel Libeskind addition to the Royal Ontario Museum, Toronto in 2009. In some uncanny way it made something happen that otherwise would not and a mundane street gained a reprieve. However, suffice to say this is not always the case. Artificiality seems a strange term to address to the built environment. More of that surely?

I tried to comment on this post last week but was unable to log on.
Teri Tynes said…
Thanks, Anton. Sorry you couldn't log on last week. There was a system-wide outage on Blogger blogs that prevented making updates and leaving comments. I couldn't even log on to let people know what was happening. Everything is back to normal.

In New York's case, preservationism became a much more vigorous pursuit in the 1960s, as many sections of the city fell to the wrecking ball. It was a particularly tough time for my neighborhood of Greenwich Village. Now the area under landmark protection has expanded. I believe this has been a positive approach, especially as the Village's identity is tied up with its older structures and meandering streets.

That said, now that the neighborhood is home to the wealthy - poor artists have been pushed out - the look of some blocks look artificial to me.

There is one school of thought that once a neighborhood is gentrified, the new ruling class of that area begins the push for preservation.

Popular posts from this blog

Museums in New York Open on Mondays

Please see this post for current announcements of reopenings . Please consult the museum websites for changes in days and hours. UPDATED September 23, 2020 Advance tickets required for many museum reopenings. Please check museum websites for details. • The  Museum of Modern Art (MoMA)  reopened to the public on  August 27 , with new hours for the first month, through September 27: from 10:30 a.m. until 5:30 p.m. Tuesday through Sunday to the public; and from 10:30 a.m. until 5:30 p.m.  on Mondays for MoMA members on ly. Admission will be free to all visitors Tuesday through Sunday, through September 27, made possible by UNIQLO. See this  new post on WOTBA for a sense of the experience attending the museum . •  New-York Historical Society  reopened on  August 14  with an outdoor exhibition, "Hope Wanted: New York City Under Quarantine,” in the rear courtyard. The exhibit by activist Kevin Powell and photographer Kay Hickman will highlight how New Yorkers weathered the quarantine

Taking a Constitutional Walk

A long time ago individuals going out for a walk, especially to get fresh air and exercise, often referred to the activity as "taking a constitutional walk." The word "constitutional" refers to one's constitution or physical makeup, so a constitutional walk was considered beneficial to one's overall wellbeing. (Or, as some would prefer to call it, "wellness.") The phrase is more common in British literature than in American letters. As early as the mid-nineteenth century, many American commentators expressed concern that their countrymen were falling into lazy and unhealthy habits. Newspaper columnists and editorial writers urged their readers to take up the practice of the "constitutional" walk. One such essay, " Walking as an Exercise," originally printed in the Philadelphia Gazette and reprinted in New England Farmer , Volume 11, 1859, urges the people of farm areas to take up walking. City dwellers seemed to have the

25 Things to Do Near the Metropolitan Museum of Art

(updated) Sitting on the steps in front of the Metropolitan Museum of Art is one of those iconic things to do in New York City. On a sunny day, the wide steps can become crowded with the young and old, the tourist and the resident. It's tempting to stay awhile and soak in the sun and the sights. Everyone has reasons for lingering there, with one being the shared pleasure of people watching along this expansive stretch of Fifth Avenue, a painting come to life. Certainly, just getting off one's feet for a moment is welcome, especially if the previous hours involved walking through the entirety of art history from prehistoric to the contemporary. The entrance to the Metropolitan Museum of Art, Fifth Avenue The Metropolitan Museum of Art should be a singular pilgrimage, uninterrupted by feeble attempts to take in more exhibitions along Museum Mile. Pity the poor visitor who tries "to do" multiple museum exhibitions in one day, albeit ambitious, noble, and uplift

25 Things To Do Near the Museum of Modern Art (MoMA)

(updated 2016) The Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) at 11 W. 53rd Street is near many other New York City attractions, so before or after a trip to the museum, a short walk in any direction could easily take in additional experiences. Drawing a square on a map with the museum at the center, a shape bounded by 58th Street to the north and 48th Street to the south, with 7th Avenue to the west and Park Avenue to the east, proves the point of the area's cultural richness. (A map follows the list below.) While well-known sightseeing stops fall with these boundaries, most notably Rockefeller Center, St. Patrick's Cathedral, and the great swath of famous Fifth Avenue stores, cultural visitors may also want to check out places such as the Austrian Cultural Forum, the 57th Street galleries, the Onassis Cultural Center, and the Municipal Art Society. The image above shows an intriguing glimpse of the tops of two Beaux-Arts buildings through an opening of the wall inside MoMA's scu

25 Radical Things to Do in Greenwich Village

A list of 25 things to Do in Greenwich Village with history of protest, old cafes, and signs of change. Hipstamatic iPhone images of contemporary Greenwich Village by Walking Off the Big Apple (Revised and updated.) Flipping through  Greenwich Village: A Photographic Guide by Edmund T. Delaney and Charles Lockwood with photographs by George Roos, a second, revised edition published in 1976, it’s easy to compare the black and white images with the look of today’s neighborhood and see how much the Village has changed. A long shot photograph of Washington Square taken up high from an apartment north of the park, and with the looming two towers of the World Trade Center off to the distant south in the background, reveals a different landscape than what we would encounter today.    On the north side of the park, an empty lot and two small buildings have since given way to NYU’s Kimmel Center and a new NYU Center for Academic and Spiritual Center Life. The Judson Memorial Church

From Penn Station to New York Landmarks: Measuring Walking Distance and Time in Manhattan

(revised 2017) How long does it take to walk from Penn Station/Madison Square Garden to well-known destinations in Manhattan? What are the best walking routes ? What if I don't want to see anything in particular but just want to walk around? In addition to the thousands of working commuters from the surrounding area, especially from New Jersey and Long Island who arrive at Penn Station via New Jersey Transit or the Long Island Rail Road, many people arrive at the station just to spend time in The City. Some have questions. Furthermore, a sporting event may have brought you to Madison Square Garden (above Penn Station), and you want to check out what the city offers near the event. This post if for you.  The map below should help you measure walking distances and times from the station to well-known destinations in Manhattan - Bryant Park , the Metropolitan Museum of Art , the Empire State Building , Times Square , Rockefeller Center , Washington Square Park , the High Line

North Towards Autumn: A Day Trip on the Metro-North Hudson Line

The peak of autumn colors in New York City tends to fall sometime in the days following Halloween, but those anxiously waiting leaf change can simply travel north.  Near Beacon, a view of autumn colors from the Metro-North Hudson line One way to speed the fall season is to take the Hudson line of Metro-North north of the city and watch the greens fade to oranges and yellows and the occasional burst of red.  Autumn light in Hastings-on-Hudson Weekends during the month of October are ideal times to make the trip. The air tends to be crisp with bright blue skies, and the Hudson River glimmers like a mirror in the light of autumn. As the Hudson line hugs the river for much of the distance north, the train ride alone provides plenty of opportunities for sightseeing. Try to grab a window seat on the river side of the train car for views of the Palisades and the bends of the Hudson Highlands later in the trip.   Autumn leaves on the Old Croton Aqueduct Trail in Hastings Still, October is a gr

A Weekend Walk on the Old Croton Aqueduct Trail

Imagine strolling from town to town near the eastern shores of the Hudson River, walking a well-trodden path lined with trees and stately architecture and with easy access to cafes, local shops, and train stations for an easy ride home. Imagine a weekend when the sun is bright and the sun is warm, and many other people - but not too many - are out enjoying the same weather and the same stroll. Such were the pleasures on a recent Sunday, in the latter part of this unseasonal winter, along the Old Croton Aqueduct Trail not too far north from New York City. View of the Hudson River from the Keeper's House The Old Croton Aqueduct, the system that once delivered fresh water from the Croton River to New York City, was a huge and complex marvel of engineering. The trail sits on top of the aqueduct system. This post describes a walk along just a section of the trail, the one that begins at the Keeper’s House in Dobbs Ferry and ends in Irvington. Recommended purchase - a map det

14 Useful Mobile Apps for Walking New York City

Texting and walking at the same time is wrong. Talking on the phone while strolling down the street is wrong. Leaving the sidewalk to stop and consult the information on a cellphone, preferably while alone, is OK. What's on Walking Off the Big Apple's iPhone: A List Walkmeter GPS Walking Stopwatch for Fitness and Weight Loss . While out walking, Walkmeter tracks routes, time, speed, and elevation. This is an excellent app for recording improvised or impromptu strolls, especially with many unplanned detours. The GPS function maps out the actual route. The app keeps a running tally of calories burned while walking, useful for weight loss goals. Another welcome feature is the ability to switch over to other modes of activity, including cycling. An indispensable app for city walkers. $4.99  New York City Compass , designed by Francesco Bertelli, is an elegant compass calibrated for Manhattan, with indications for Uptown, East Side, Downtown, and West Side. While facing a cert

The High Line and Chelsea Market: A Good Pairing for a Walk

(revised 2017) The advent of spring, with its signs of growth and rebirth, is apparent both on the High Line , where volunteers are cutting away the old growth to reveal fresh blooms, and inside the Chelsea Market, where new tenants are revitalizing the space. A walk to take in both can become an exploration of bounty and surprise, a sensual walk of adventure and sustenance. A good pairing for a walk: The High Line and Chelsea Market Walking the High Line for a round trip from Gansevoort to W. 30th and then back again adds up to a healthy 2-mile walk. Regular walkers of the elevated park look for an excuse to go there. Especially delightful is showing off the park, a model of its kind, to visitors from out of town. A stroll through Chelsea Market. Time check. If you haven't stopped into Chelsea Market lately, you may want to take a detour from the High Line at the stairs on W. 16th St. and walk through the market for a quick assessment or a sampling. Among the sampli